- Saint John
- Saint Paul
- Salem
- Saltillo
- Saratoga
- Selma
- Seymour
- Shelbyville
- Sheridan
- Shirley
- Sidney
- Silver Lake
- Somerville
- Southport
- Spencer
- Spring Grove
- Spring Lake
- Star City
- Staunton
- Sullivan
- Sulphur Springs
- Syracuse
- Saint Joe
- Santa Claus
- Scottsburg
- Sharpsville
- South Haven
- Springport
- Spurgeon
- State Line