- Pataukunk
- Patchin
- Patchinville
- Patchogue Highlands
- Patent
- Pathfinder Island
- Patria
- Patroon Island
- Pattens Mills
- Patterson
- Pattersonville
- Pattersonville-Rotterdam Junction
- Pattersquash Island
- Paul Smiths
- Paul Smiths Easy Street
- Paulies Mobile Home Park
- Pavilion
- Pavilion Center
- Payne Beach
- Paynesville
- Pea Brook
- Pea Island
- Peach Island
- Peach Island
- Peakville
- Pearl Creek
- Pearsalls Hassock
- Peas Eddy
- Peas Eddy Island
- Peasleeville