- Pishak Island
- Pit Rock
- Pitt Island
- Pittman
- Pleasant Harbour
- Pleasant Island
- Pleasure Island
- Pleiades Islands
- Plover Islands
- Plum Island Rocks
- Pluma Island
- Poa Island
- Pocket Island
- Poe Island
- Point Lockwood Rock
- Point Possession
- Point Swift Rock
- Pointed Island
- Pointed Rock
- Pole Island
- Polivnoi Rock
- Polk Inlet
- Polk Island
- Polly Island
- Poltava Island
- Pomeroy Island
- Pond Island
- Poorman
- Pope-Vannoy Landing
- Poperechnoi Island